In partnership with
What do these names have in common?
Arnold Schwarzenegger
Codie Sanchez
Scott Galloway
Colin & Samir
Shaan Puri
Jay Shetty
They all run their businesses on beehiiv. Newsletters, websites, digital products, and more. beehiiv is the only platform you need to take your content business to the next level.
🚨Limited time offer: Get 30% off your first 3 months on beehiiv. Just use code JOIN30 at checkout.
Agile coaches are disappearing. Once seen as the heroes of transformation, they’re now quietly being cut from budgets. The question is: why?
I was reminded of this recently at a year-end celebration with my team. Our Agile coach asked me:
“Do you miss being a full-time coach?”
I answered too quickly: “Not really. I still practice the craft, but the job itself feels broken.”
That moment made me reflect: if I, someone who deeply believes in agility, feel this way, no wonder organisations are moving on.
Why Agile Coaches Are Dying Out
1. Agile Theatre Instead of Real Agility
Most companies run ceremonies without embracing the mindset. Leaders see daily stand-ups and retros, then ask: “Do we really need to pay a coach for this?”
👉 I once saw an organisation cancel its coaching program after three quarters because “all we got were more meetings.” The coach had no way to prove that delivery improved.
2. The Certification Cartel
Let’s be controversial: Agile certification has become a pay-to-play industry.
To move up, you don’t need experience, just money for private sessions with the very people who later evaluate your submission.
Result? Armies of paper-certified coaches with zero scars from the battlefield.
A better model: theory exam + live case evaluation by randomly selected peers. Accessible, fair, and based on proven experience — not money.
3. Reporting into the Wrong Power Structures
If coaches report to product or tech leads, they’re politically neutered. How can you challenge leadership when they control your performance review?
4. Focusing on Therapy, Not Outcomes
Coaches often emphasise team “happiness” over delivery speed, quality, or customer impact. Well-being is crucial — but if that’s all you can prove, your role looks like HR with sticky notes.
5. Inexperience and Lack of Mentorship
Junior coaches are hired because they’re cheaper. Without experienced mentors, they parrot frameworks instead of diagnosing systemic issues.
The Deeper Structural Problem
The Agile community itself became insular. Coaches only talk to other coaches, recycle frameworks, and stay in their bubble. Meanwhile, the industry has moved on.
👉 Today’s Agile coach needs to discuss:
TDD and DevOps practices
DORA metrics (lead time, deployment frequency, MTTR)
North Star metrics and driver trees
Org design and systems thinking
If you can’t speak the language of engineers and executives, you’ll be dismissed as irrelevant.
Old-School Coach vs. Modern Coach
Old-School Agile Coach | Modern Organisational Coach |
|---|---|
Runs retros and stand-ups | Designs KPIs, tracks delivery outcomes |
Talks “ceremonies” | Talks “systems, incentives, and flow” |
Obsessed with certifications | Obsessed with impact |
Reports into product/tech | Reports into PMO, People, or CIO |
Focuses on team therapy | Focuses on business outcomes |
What Coaches Must Do to Survive
Grow Horizontally with Hard Skills
Learn analytics, metrics, TDD, and system design. If you can’t explain why CI/CD improves cycle time, you’re outdated.Think Systemically
Teams aren’t the real issue — structures, incentives, and silos are. Coaches must go beyond linear, team-level fixes.Deliver Business Results
Tie your work to measurable outcomes:Lead time down 20%
Defect rate cut in half
Time-to-market accelerated by weeks
Step Outside Employment (Eventually)
Internal coaches get politically captured. Contractors and consultants have the independence to push uncomfortable truths.Stop Being Just “Agile”
Expand into leadership coaching, change management, and strategy. Agility is a means, not the end.
A 30-60-90 Day Agile Coach Survival Plan
First 30 Days
Audit current teams and systemic blockers
Collect baseline metrics: cycle time, throughput, deployment frequency
Identify quick wins (e.g., reduce WIP, shorten feedback loops)
Next 60 Days
Run workshops with leadership to surface systemic blockers
Start connecting Agile outcomes to business metrics (faster delivery, higher NPS)
Mentor junior coaches or Scrum Masters to scale influence
Next 90 Days
Redesign reporting to show impact dashboards (not just ceremonies)
Expand scope: partner with product, engineering, and people ops
Publish measurable success: “Our lead time went from 21 days to 9.”
Provocative Questions to Ponder
If Agile is now a basic skill for PMs and engineers, do we even need Agile coaches anymore?
Is the role dying — or is it simply evolving into something bigger (organisational coach, transformation advisor)?
What if the real problem isn’t Agile coaching — but the business model of the Agile industry itself?
What Organisations Must Do
Support coaches with autonomy and resources — not bury them under product leads.
Hire for scars, not certificates. Look for coaches who’ve lived through real transformations.
Create horizontal career paths. Coaching isn’t linear; it should branch into strategy, people leadership, or transformation roles.
Measure outcomes objectively. Use cycle time, throughput, DORA metrics, and customer impact — not “team happiness” alone.
Show exec visibility. Share clear before-and-after metrics with top leadership.
The Future Outlook: AI and the Fourth Industrial Revolution
Here’s the twist: as AI takes over backlog prioritisation, sprint planning, and even retrospective insights, the Agile coach of the future won’t survive by running ceremonies.
The next generation of coaches will:
Facilitate organisational agility, not just team agility
Coach leaders in decision-making under uncertainty
Use AI tools to diagnose bottlenecks, freeing time for systemic change
In short, Agile coaches must reinvent themselves as organisational performance coaches for the AI era.
The Harsh Reality
Agile coaching was born out of rebellion in 2001. Twenty-four years later, it risks becoming an industry of hollow certifications, superficial adoption, and roles stripped of influence.
But this doesn’t have to be the end. If coaches evolve — if they prove impact, grow technical literacy, and think systemically — the role won’t just survive. It will matter more than ever.
👉 Final Thought:
Do you believe Agile coaching can reinvent itself for the AI era — or are we simply watching the natural end of the role?
💡 If you enjoyed this article and want exclusive playbooks, premium toolkits, and advanced insights into product management, agile transformation, and leadership, consider subscribing to Cooking Agile Premium.
For only €7/month or €70/year, you’ll unlock:
Premium articles and deep-dive essays
Downloadable frameworks and toolkits
Case studies from real-world transformations
👉 Join Cooking Agile Premium today and take your career — and your teams — to the next level.